Reviews of Romeo's Pizza in Pickerington, OH

About Us

At Romeo’s Pizza, we believe that great pizza starts with simple, high-quality ingredients—hand-tossed dough, vine-ripened tomatoes, and fresh, hand-cut vegetables. Our award-winning recipes and warm, neighborly service aim to make every visit feel like coming home. More than just a pizza place, we’re part of the community—supporting local teams, giving back, and striving to leave a positive footprint wherever we serve.

Categories

Pizza Restaurant Italian Restaurant Takeout Restaurant / Takeaway Delivery Restaurant Fast Casual Restaurant
Share:

Customer Reviews

The reviews provided do not represent all available feedback. They offer a selection of opinions, but there may be other reviews that aren't included in this summary.

"
GA

Garing Armstead

5 /5
Jazelle is awesome!! when it comes to customer service she sets the tone. She knows me by name when I come in down to the 2 garlic sauces I get. Anytime I go to a diff pizza place I compare them to those Romeos and they don’t match up. I’ve seen them packed and she keeps her composure and her smile all the time. She’s the main reason I keep coming back to Romeos as much as I do
"
P

Paul

5 /5
Jazelle was amazing and helped increase my experience in a positive way with you all. She has been an incredible host. I have had the same consistent experience with her the last 4 times that I have ordered from you all. She is definitely one of the reasons that I have returned. I truly appreciate her hospitality and she is an outstanding representative of Romeos Pizza. Thanks!
"
P

Paula

5 /5
Jazelle was great at taking care of our order and great customer service!!
"
T

Trinity

5 /5
Ethan was so kind and respectful and got here in a timely manner.
"
A

Aaron

5 /5
Ethan was on time and courteous. Thanks!
"
P

Paul

5 /5
People on the phone do a great job. They help me with my order. The people at the counter seem to know me and are reaching for my pizza before I even get through the door. I am an old man and they restore my faith in todays youth.
"
LR

Laura Roesch

5 /5
Jazelle is the best! She is friendly, professional and recognizes me every time I come, and even has my order waiting. The food is excellent.
"
BJ

Brian Jett

5 /5
Jazelle was wonderful at your Pickerington location. Top notch.
"
SW

Sara Wilson

5 /5
I love coming into your store for the BOGO Tuesday pizza deal. Whenever Jazelle is working, she sees me come in the door, walks over to the pizza holding area and hands me my pizza. I don’t even have to say who I am. She is always so pleasant and has a smile on her face! Love your store! Thanks for the great service!
"
Z

Ziggy

5 /5
I love this place! It’s my Tuesday spot. And Jazelle makes the experience so much more enjoyable. She is a hard, friendly worker that makes every visit better.
"
J

Jazelle

5 /5
Jazelle has always been very polite to my 3 year old son and I. Great service will keep me coming back.
"
S

Saira

5 /5
Jazelle made a amazing pizza and her service is amazing
"
J

Jazelle

5 /5
Love the pizza and will miss is since we moved to Granville!
"
J

Jazelle

5 /5
Great service and good as always!
"
TM

Tim M

5 /5
Jazelle was delightful and the pizza was delicious!!
"
MR

Malia Richardson

5 /5
Today I ordered chicken and it was fresh well done and delicious, exactly what I asked for. Thanks Emily for working in excellence!
"
B

Bryan

5 /5
Jeff smells like cheese

Reviews are independently collected and verified. Individual results may vary.

See what sets us apart.

Discover why people choose Romeo's Pizza. Ready to connect? Choose how you'd like to reach out.