Reviews of Great Florida Insurance in Cape Coral, FL
4.9
Categories:
Homeowners Insurance, Auto Insurance,, Homeowners Insurance, Auto Insurance,, Homeowners Insurance, Auto Insurance,
Contact Information:
Business Description:
GreatFlorida Insurance is a network of independent, franchised insurance agents located throughout Florida. With 128 locations throughout Florida, it is easy to find a GreatFlorida Agency in your neighborhood.
We provide 24-hour service, 7 days a week, 365 days a year, through our partnered insurance companies.
Our Independent, GreatFlorida Insurance Agents will help you find affordable Insurance in Florida to protect you and your family.
Reviews: The reviews provided do not represent all available feedback. They offer a selection of opinions, but there may be other reviews that aren't included in this summary.
Great Florida Insurance
Blaise Fortunato
November 20, 2026
Courtney is absolutely the best. Every year she saves me a lot of money. She goes above and beyond my expectations. Great Florida is very lucky they have her. I hope to have a long and fruitful experience dealing with her and the company for years to come.
Great Florida Insurance
Nancy Reese
November 19, 2026
Winners all around!
Sandy was wonderful getting us great coverage and prices on both homeowners and auto insurance. Will recommend to all my friends and family!
Great Florida Insurance
Noreen McDermott
November 19, 2026
Courtney Line was very professional and got back to me in a timely manner
Great Florida Insurance
Jeffrey Scholten
November 18, 2026
Sandy did an exceptional job at explaining our coverage and what our best options would be. Insurance can be confusing at times, nice to have someone explain the ins and outs.
Great Florida Insurance
Barry Stephens
November 16, 2026
Sandy showed me all the coverage options. She listened to my concerns and was very efficient with her responses to my questions. She also compared price and value in our meeting. I would highly recommend Sandy to anyone looking for great service with a smile!
Great Florida Insurance
Ronald Tigges
November 13, 2026
I had nothing but the best service from Sandy Nivens in the Cape Coral office over the last couple weeks.
Sandy provided me with mulitple qoutes and found us the best fit auto and home insurance for my wife and I.
Start to finish she made every step painless.
I look forward to working with her in the future.
Great Florida Insurance
Patrick Caronna
November 18, 2026
I'd like to thank you for your hard work also for your attentiveness and professionalism. Sandy was a tremendous help in finding what I needed and always kept me well informed.
Great Florida Insurance
CHRISTOPHER CALLAHAN
November 11, 2026
Elaine was more than helpful when it came to fixing issues with both my insurance and my brothers. Will definitely work with her again in the future.
Great Florida Insurance
JORGE HERNANDEZ
October 30, 2026
Iliana es una buena persona y nos ayuda mucho estoy contenta con ella
Great Florida Insurance
Carmen Basile
October 29, 2026
Excellent experience with getting home and auto insurance. Courtney was great to work with and she found me good deals on home and auto.
Great Florida Insurance
Niyired Molina
October 28, 2026
Elaine has always been extremely helpful every time we have a question or a concern regarding our insurance.
Great Florida Insurance
VINCENT CONTESSA
October 30, 2026
My experience with Great Florida has been outstanding. Their professionalism and attention to detail is unmatched. Simply put they afforded me the opportunity to meld my input with their superior expertise. And today you have a very satisfied customer. I look forward to doing more business with Great Florida Insurance in the future. Elaine was at the top of her game and is a key member of this company.
Great Florida Insurance
Joseph Schneeloch
October 19, 2026
Good service, very responsive to my emails and calls. Very knowledgeable of her job.
Great Florida Insurance
John Korf
October 9, 2026
Courtney was a great help with her knowledge for us to select the right insurance. And Courtney was very timely with our insurance needs
Great Florida Insurance
Sylvester Smalls
October 7, 2026
Great Experience and quick response. Excellent.
Great Florida Insurance
David Kainrad
October 11, 2026
I have worked with Great Florida Insurance Co. for years; and with each home owner insurance renewal, I am impressed with the company's response to any inquiry's made. I have been blessed by having a company team member Sandy Nivens, handle both my home owner and car insurance needs. The company is sensitive to the overall needs of its clients. Sandy was able to secure a new home owner insurance policy that is almost $2,000.00 less this year than the last policy coverage, plus the overall coverage is better. She also found a car insurance company that is providing better coverage while saving us $1,600 / year. In summary, the Great Florida Insurance Co. is a professional, exemplary and caring company. Without any reservation, I can wholeheartedly support and recommend Florida Great Insurance Co. for your insurance needs. It is truly a "Great" company!
Great Florida Insurance
Judith Galewski
September 28, 2026
Very satisfying experience. Found what I needed quickly with minimum effort on my part Experienced staff and quick response. Reduced my payment significantly. Sandy was helpful and friendly.
Great Florida Insurance
Nancy Thorne
September 24, 2026
Sandy Nivens is always quick to respond and professional. A pleasure to do business with. A great company !
Great Florida Insurance
KEVIN KEIRNS
September 25, 2026
My experience with Mrs. Modugno was extremely helpful in explaining the coverages, returning my emails and working with me to provide me with the coverage I needed at a price I could afford. I know you are only asking about the coverage, responsiveness and price but without a person to help explain, modify be there for you, going with a cheap price isn't always the best route to take. Mrs. Modugno replied to my emails quickly and called when there was a misunderstanding on my part to help iron it out. thanks to her explaining the coverages, helped to lower the price that helped me to go with this insurance provider.
Great Florida Insurance
Tom Scopp
September 23, 2026
Great team. Very friendly and efficient. And best price quotes. And convenient.
Great Florida Insurance
Nathan Celauro
September 21, 2026
Sandy was very helpful and informative.
Great Florida Insurance
Bennett Orlowski
September 21, 2026
Sandy Niven is terrific almost cut my home owners in half. Now the second year she lowered again. This is the first time in my life (77years) an insurance person was looking out for me. I’m telling everyone where to go for insurance see Sandy!
Great Florida Insurance
Susan
September 16, 2026
Outstanding Performance and representative!!
Great Florida Insurance
Jurij Lazar
September 24, 2026
Sandy, our agent was very thorough in reviewing and updating us regarding our insurance policies. She was very knowledgeable and we felt comfortable to move our current policies to Great Florida Insurance.
We are very pleased to have her as our agent.
Thanks again for spending time with us.
Great Florida Insurance
Kimberly Pennino
September 10, 2026
Love that Sandy is constantly checking to get us better prices!
Great Florida Insurance
Robert Miller
September 9, 2026
My insurance coverage and experience over the last several years
has been with Great Florida Insurance. My agent, Sandy Nivens, is outstanding. She is knowledgeable, very professional, and personable. She will get you the best coverage for the most competitive premium. She always returns calls and emails.
I would go nowhere else for Florida insurance.
Great Florida Insurance
Judith
September 10, 2026
Thank you for the excellent service!!
It was time to review our car insurance.
Elaine was very helpful in find a new provider at a much lower cost!
Thank you for all your help it is appreciated
Great Florida Insurance
JAMES LASTER
September 3, 2026
Thanks Elaine for getting me the best car insurance rate.
Great Florida Insurance
Charles Battaglia
August 24, 2026
THANK YOU SO MUCH SANDY. BEEN WITH YOU FOR SIX OR SEVEN YEARS NOW, AND YOU ALWAYS COME THROUGH. I COULDN'T BE MORE PLEASED. THANKS AGAIN CHUCK
Great Florida Insurance
Michael Nachurski
August 21, 2026
Sandy Nivens is the best. Responsive and looked out for my best interest. Couldn't asked for a better agent
Great Florida Insurance
Maura A.
August 3, 2026
Courtney continues to be an exceptional asset for this company. She has been professional, extremely helpful, and very responsive to all of my inquiries. I am very pleased to be able to work with her.
Great Florida Insurance
Gretchen Bennett
August 2, 2026
What a breath of fresh honest air! We were looking for auto insurance and seeing how honest Sandy Nivens was, we decided to include our house also!
Another Happy Customer
Gretchen Bennett
Great Florida Insurance
KEVIN KEIRNS
July 30, 2026
The Agent I used was Elaine Modugno and she was the nicest, most knowledgeable and patient agent I have ever worked with. She was extremely helpful and when the one insurance denied me because of no fire hydrant within 1,000 feet, she immediately started the work to get me back with my previous insurance company. Thank you very much and I would encourage anyone to contact her to sit up your insurance policies.
Great Florida Insurance
LYNNA BAKER
July 30, 2026
My experience with GreatFlorida Insurance was great! Elaine Modugno (2125 Santa Barbara Blvd, Cape Coral, Fl) helped me with my new Home Owners Insurance policy. She was very pleasant, patient, and very knowledgeable. Elaine is a great asset to your team at GreatFlorida Insurance!
Lynna Baker
Great Florida Insurance
ROSE VERGE
July 29, 2026
Elaine has always gone above and beyond to help me with adding all my kids to car insurance and with home owner policies . She is the best
Great Florida Insurance
ALEKSSIE FUNES
July 29, 2026
It was very good, good customer service, information easy to understand.
Great Florida Insurance
BS
August 6, 2026
Outstanding customer service—calls are always answered, the staff are very friendly, communication is prompt and responsive, and, above all, the customer's personal needs are addressed to find the optimal insurance solution.
Special thanks go to your representative Sandy, who handles all our personal insurance matters and fulfills the aforementioned service criterias to our complete satisfaction.
Great Florida Insurance
Sandra Roberts
July 27, 2026
This was one of the smoothes experiences I have encountered in a long time.
Sandra asked all the detailed questions I needed and was able to explain different parts of the insurance policy. She saved me over 5k in home owners insurance. I have been with USAA in many facets of insurance, yet, it was time to change. Over insured cost me alot of money.
When my current insurance rates couldnt be beat, I was told that too. Still saving me more money.
Its really nice having a local agent that I can call and deal with.
Than you Sandra, this has been great.
Great Florida Insurance
Steven Floyd
July 21, 2026
Courtney is awesome. She answers all our questions and helps us to decide which insurance company to go with. Thanks Courtney for all your hard work.
Great Florida Insurance
Janice Freund
July 20, 2026
We can always count on Great Florida Insurance to find us the best deal at the best price. Our compliments and thanks to Sandy for doing such an excellent job for us!!
Great Florida Insurance
LINDA COLLIN
July 17, 2026
Great Florida Insurance is an excellent company that is very knowledgeable, helpful, friendly, & answers any questions that I have. A Special Thank You to Courtney & Sandy as well as all the staff for the Excellent Customer Service.
Great Florida Insurance
Sherry Carey
July 12, 2026
My agent Sandy Niven was efficient and helped simplify my home/auto policies. I appreciate her help.
Great Florida Insurance
Kathleen Fiore
July 6, 2026
My agent Sandy Nivens is very knowledgeable and professional.She is a great representative for your company. You feel like you are talking to a relative not an sales person.
Great Florida Insurance
Joseph McGee
June 29, 2026
Very pleased with Ashley and GREATFLORIDA.Ashley shopped and compared auto policies for me and was able to save me a significant amount of money.Great customer service.
Great Florida Insurance
Jerry Buonocore
June 25, 2026
Sandy was very professional.
Polite. friendly and knowledgeable.
Great Florida Insurance
Vincent Sorrenti
June 15, 2026
Very satisfied looking out for there customers
Great Florida Insurance
Debra Street
June 4, 2026
Sandy is a great agent. She is very responsive and takes the initiative to call us with a caring compassionate attitude. We have been involved in two accidents since coming to Florida and she has reached out to provide us assistance in both instances. I highly recommend her and have sent three couples her way that were very happy with her assistance.
Great Florida Insurance
Dana Brinker
June 1, 2026
I have been working with you guys for about 30 years. You’re fabulous. I love my lady Sandy that takes care of me. She was there through thick and thin in the hurricane and she’s a pleasure to deal with.
Great Florida Insurance
D Melcher
June 18, 2026
Sandy helped me update my insurance. Was very happy with what she did for me. Glad I made the change to GreatFlorida Insurance.
Great Florida Insurance
John Blom
May 18, 2026
Sandy Nivens, was super helpful and communicated very well throughout the whole process. Saved me a ton of money on homeowners and auto insurance! 5 star all around!

